Sheriff, Chief get into verbal spat during Candidate’s forum

Remaining Ad Time Ad - 00:00

Debate turned into argument during the latest NAACP Peoria County Sheriff’s Candidate Forum Tuesday.

During the open question session, a member of the crowd asked Bartonville Police Chief Brian Fengel why County units were involved during a police incident in Bartonville October 2nd on Shelley Lane.

“Now, don’t get me wrong – whenever another agency needs help, that’s what we’re there for,” explained Peoria County Sheriff Brian Asbell. “We’re there to assist each other.”

“It wasn’t handled by the Sheriff’s department, it was handled by our police department,” Chief Fengel is heard saying in the video on Facebook. “We were in charge of it, County came in as officer backup.”

Sheriff Asbell said the incident in question was a contentious one, due to how the two departments chose to report it.

Chief Fengel’s press release described the incident as a gas leak. Sheriff Asbell’s, however, said it was a suicidal individual planning on causing a gas explosion.

During Sheriff Asbell’s response at the forum, he made a comment directed back at Chief Fengel.

“Sorry, Chief, you weren’t there,” he can be heard saying. “My officers were there, and they managed the situation.”

Then came the retort: “That’s a lie,” shot back Chief Fengel. “I was there. You were not there. You sent officers to back us up, plain and simple. Let’s tell the facts, okay? You weren’t there, I was.”

The conversation devolved from there, eventually with Sheriff Asbell saying he would make a Freedom of Information Act request for the Bartonville officer’s body and dash camera video – which he filed Wednesday.

Chief Fengel agreed, saying it was a matter of his credibility as well, and that his department was cooperating.

“I knew it would be coming. So what we did was get all the evidence, police reports, all the videos,” he explained. “We’re currently reviewing it, and we’re going to comply with the FOIA.”

Chief Fengel also added the investigation into the October 2nd incident was concluded and, as such, the information Sheriff Asbell was seeking would be readily available.



More News
Dry and Cool Weather to Stay

Dry and Cool Weather to Stay

Below normal temperatures will continue for the next several days as a dry and cool air mass overhead controls our

Connect With 25 News
Top Stories

Limestone teacher accused of sexual harassment, lawsuit filed against school district

 UPDATE: Peoria County Sheriff Brian Asbell confirms his department will be handling the criminal case. An order of protection

Breaking News: Shots Fired

It was reported a shooting in the 200 block of East McClure Ave. The shooting effected two people. One male

Attorney Speaks About Reasons Behind Pritzker Campaign Lawsuit

Nearly a dozen people who work for the JB Pritzker campaign are now suing, with claims of discrimination and harassment.

Eureka College announces program including free tuition

The Peoria Promise Foundation celebrated 10 years of service over the weekend. The organization provides free tuition to Illinois Central

Mural, Uptown diner to be demolished for tax-generating office space

On Monday, the Normal Town Council decided to move ahead with the next stage of the Uptown Development Project. The

Scroll to top
Skip to content